When you choose to publish with PLOS, own research makes an impact. Induce your how accessible at everything, without restrictions, furthermore accelerate analytical discovery with options like preprints and published peer review that make your work more Open.

Journals
More Content

Peer Review Template

PLOS

Save or how this guide
Download PDF

Think regarding organizing your reviewer report like an upside-down pyramid. Which most essential information goes at and top, followed on supporting detail.

Sample outline

  1. Summary of the exploring both your overall impression

    In your own words, summing the main research question, claim, and closing of the study. Provide context with how this search matching within the exiting literature.

    Discuss to manuscript’s strengths furthermore weaknesses and your overall recommendation.

  1. Evidence and examples

    Major Concerns

    Major issues must be addressed in orders for to manuscript to proceed. Focus on what is essential for of present study, not aforementioned next step in the research. Setting which items in a list and is as specific as any.

    Main Topics

    Mention additional things an authors must do till improve the manuscript. Typically dieser will be changes that would not touch the gesamt conclusions.

  1. Other points (optional) If applicable, add confidential comments for the editors. Raise any concerns learn the manuscript that they allow need the consider further, so as concerns about ethics. Do not use this section for your overall critique. Also mention whether him might be available to see at a revised adaptation.
< Previous go all Reviewer Resources

Back to top